Pushing Buttons - The Blog

How to make the hard things work well - exploration, engagement, excitement, and by pushing a few buttons.

the Friday edition - the one about AI and SEO

the Friday edition - the one about AI and SEO

May 23, 20253 min read

This week, a client forwarded me a dramatically worded sales pitch they’d received about AI. And SEO. And how everything we knew was just “blown up”.

I could go on about my disdain for dramatic sales pitches disguised as service or how much I loathe “______ is dead” social posts, but I’m going to spare you all that. If you read my emails most weeks, you probably are with me there anyway.

I rarely go into marketing or AI specifics here, but I always want my clients and subscribers to feel like they are keeping up or at least not falling behind. So this edition is dedicated to giving you a little insight you can use with your teams if you happen to be involved in marketing for your company.

So what happened? Two things.

  1. This week, ChatGPT users started seeing a new option to download a Chrome extension that would then default any searches to go through ChatGPT vs. Google. It looked like this for me:

ChatGPT extension prompt
  1. Whether using the extension or not, ChatGPT started testing a roll out of map results for searches that it makes sense for. Like “Reputable electricians near me”

map showing reputable electricians near me

So is Google search (and Ads) as we know it dead? (I hate that I wrote that.)

No - search is fragmenting, not disappearing. Expect a dual-channel world where Google and AI agents coexist for at least the next 24 months.

AI is using the sources we should already be investing in - see my loom about this here.

Watch the Loom


Things to know (co-authored with ChatGPT)

Early AEO (AI Experience Optimization) is a competitive edge.

It’s estimated that 80% of what LLMs will likely use is based on existing SEO tactics - structured data, good content, being in local listings and maps (not just Google). Checking on these and ensuring you are generating LLM-friendly content will position you to capture share as the shifts happen.

– Brands with clean schema, authoritative content, and consistent local data will influence answer boxes and map pilots.

– Laggards risk losing “recommendation real estate” even if they still rank in Google.

– Think “Answer Share.” Add a quarterly KPI: % of priority queries in ChatGPT that cite or display our assets. Manual today, but priceless for spotting gaps.

– Structured data is now table stakes. Budget developer hours soon to harden or add JSON-LD across all high-value pages before the next model refresh.

Things to not do

  • Panic

  • Stop Ads

    • instead start monitoring for impact (see Things to do)

    • ring-fence 10% of search spend for experimentation in conversational ad formats

    • consider testing similar campaigns in Bing for both investment diversity and data insights

Things to do

  • Check on your SEO strategy and effectiveness

  • Add structured data to your site asap if you haven’t already

  • Have your team set up reporting in Analytics to monitor traffic from referral sources - in most cases, chatGPT is adding
    “?utm_source=chatgpt.com” to the links in their results. Similarly, I was able to see one of my clients was getting Perplexity traffic as well.

Are you ahead of the game already? Any other tips you would share? Want a little help thinking it through for your company? Just email us back!

Until next week,

Rebecca and the Advisory 9 team

AIReferralsCustomGPTChatGPTSEO
blog author image

Rebecca Whitney

Founder and CEO of Advisory 9

Back to Blog

the Friday Edition

Join our weekly newsletter for a bit of fun and inspiration!

Each week, we share our thoughts on:

- AI and other tools that we're using or testing

- Ad campaigns that we find interesting

- Marketing insights from life experiences

- (very) Occasional first access to courses and resources

I agree to receive email communication, updates, and offers from Advisory 9. I can opt-out at any time - no hard feelings!

Advisory 9 is women and US Veteran owned.